It's been at least two years since I read "Iolokus" from beginning to end so I can't respond to every point you've made. I get why the characterizations didn't work for you--heck, they didn't work for a lot of people, even some people who love the fic. (Read through the comments for reader-responses from some of the fandom best-known writers.) The darn writers for the series couldn't keep them in character half the time. Describing "Iolokus" as "all heavy-handed bitterness and fire" without nuance is oversimplified, although I will grant the fic is purposefully short on subtlety. *g*
The fic was written out of anger, in reaction to events of the series through season five, in particular what was done to Scully. She's abducted by Duane Barry and Donnie Pfaster; she's given cancer; she's turned into a guinea pig by the Consortium doctors, who commit medical rape by stealing her ova and using them to make human/alien clones. But that wasn't enough for the writers: in Christmas Carol/Emily, Scully gets to discover that they've used her ova to make a very sick little girl, just so that Scully can suffer, suffer and suffer some more. I'm getting angry myself, just thinking about it. I can't imagine watching it unfold in real time. (I first watched the series in order in 2006-07 when the slimsets were released on DVD.)
This story is wildly ambitious, and to my mind, the writers mostly succeed at what they're attempting to do: they want to show us how angry and insane Mulder and Scully should be, given all that they've been put through by the damned writers. It's not comforting and it's not easy reading. That's a good thing, imho, given the issues they're dealing with. But--if you make it all the way to the end, to Syadiloh 1 and 2, we (and Mulder and Scully) get rewarded for our suffering, and that alone makes it worthwhile.
The complete Iolokus Series is now at AO3, as well as at Gossamer. I should edit the post to reflect that.
If you want me to add you to the community roster so that you can post unscreened, I'd be happy to do so. I have commenting set to screen non-members for spam prevention.
Thanks for taking the time to comment. It means a lot to know that people are still reading the fic and finding the community.
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png){kind=small}
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
winterfish
No thread is ever dead
Date: 2016-05-15 03:31 am (UTC)It's been at least two years since I read "Iolokus" from beginning to end so I can't respond to every point you've made. I get why the characterizations didn't work for you--heck, they didn't work for a lot of people, even some people who love the fic. (Read through the comments for reader-responses from some of the fandom best-known writers.) The darn writers for the series couldn't keep them in character half the time. Describing "Iolokus" as "all heavy-handed bitterness and fire" without nuance is oversimplified, although I will grant the fic is purposefully short on subtlety. *g*
The fic was written out of anger, in reaction to events of the series through season five, in particular what was done to Scully. She's abducted by Duane Barry and Donnie Pfaster; she's given cancer; she's turned into a guinea pig by the Consortium doctors, who commit medical rape by stealing her ova and using them to make human/alien clones. But that wasn't enough for the writers: in Christmas Carol/Emily, Scully gets to discover that they've used her ova to make a very sick little girl, just so that Scully can suffer, suffer and suffer some more. I'm getting angry myself, just thinking about it. I can't imagine watching it unfold in real time. (I first watched the series in order in 2006-07 when the slimsets were released on DVD.)
This story is wildly ambitious, and to my mind, the writers mostly succeed at what they're attempting to do: they want to show us how angry and insane Mulder and Scully should be, given all that they've been put through by the damned writers. It's not comforting and it's not easy reading. That's a good thing, imho, given the issues they're dealing with. But--if you make it all the way to the end, to Syadiloh 1 and 2, we (and Mulder and Scully) get rewarded for our suffering, and that alone makes it worthwhile.
The complete Iolokus Series is now at AO3, as well as at Gossamer. I should edit the post to reflect that.
If you want me to add you to the community roster so that you can post unscreened, I'd be happy to do so. I have commenting set to screen non-members for spam prevention.
Thanks for taking the time to comment. It means a lot to know that people are still reading the fic and finding the community.